Ecommerce fees comparison: total store operating cost

Compare ecommerce fees using the same catalogue and order workload, including platform, payment, app and upkeep rather than a headline plan price.

An ecommerce fees comparison must price the same store workload, including payments and staff time. Shopify Grow lists $114 a month on yearly billing, before applicable subscription tax. WooCommerce’s core platform has no monthly subscription. Neither figure is a complete store budget.

Compare the full cost over your intended ownership period, then test what happens when orders or staffing change. A lower subscription can lose its advantage when it needs more paid applications or manual recovery work.

Set a comparable workload

Give every supplier the same catalogue and operating requirements before comparing ecommerce pricing. Total cost of ownership (TCO) is the cost of setting up, running and eventually changing or leaving the arrangement over a defined period.

Separate setup payments from recurring charges. Usage-based fees rise with orders, payment volume or another measured activity. Internal operating work consumes staff time even when no supplier sends an invoice.

Use a written workload such as this fictional Australian store:

  • The catalogue has 500 products and 2,000 sellable variants, with stock held at one location.
  • One online storefront takes 1,000 successful orders a month, averaging $80 collected per order. There is one successful payment per order.
  • All payments in the base case use domestic online cards. International cards and alternative payment methods enter separate scenarios.
  • Two staff need their own working accounts, with the owner’s account separate. The store also needs an accounting connection and a shipping-label workflow.
  • Each proposal must cover variant stock updates, paid-order export, fulfilment tracking and a refund reaching the accounting records.

Specify whether the amount collected includes delivery and product tax. Payment fees can apply to the collected amount, not just the merchandise value. Keep failed payments, refunds and disputes separate from successful orders so their charges are visible.

Choose a comparison period, such as three years. Show first-year cash payments separately from later years because migration and annual prepayments can make the first year more expensive.

Cost the actual retail workflow

Price the complete path from a changed product record to a reconciled order. An included catalogue feature does not establish that your accounting or shipping connection is included.

Shopify’s Australian pricing page lists Grow at $114 a month billed yearly, or $1,368 for the year before applicable subscription tax. Grow includes up to five staff accounts. Basic lists $42 a month billed yearly, but excludes additional staff accounts, so it fails the fictional store’s staffing requirement.

Shopify lists hosting as included. Its Grow online standard card rate is 1.55% plus $0.30 per transaction. Applied only to the fictional store’s $80,000 eligible monthly card volume and 1,000 payments, that gives $1,540 in processing fees. This is a calculation using the listed rate, not a total store quote.

Shopify’s Australian subscription tax guidance says 10% goods and services tax (GST) applies unless the business registers for Australian GST and adds its Australian Business Number to the store. Its payment tax guidance says Shopify Payments processing fees already include GST. Avoid adding GST twice to those fees.

WooCommerce’s pricing page describes a free core platform with separate hosting and extensions. It also separates the payment processor’s fees from the platform cost. A WooCommerce proposal therefore needs a named host, selected extensions and a maintenance service or internal owner before it is comparable with a hosted subscription.

Do not copy another country’s card rates or a global hosting estimate into an Australian proposal. Obtain the actual local tariff and contract for each required component. Keep its currency, tax basis and renewal term beside the amount.

Cost lines for the same order workflow

Cost lineWhat belongs in the comparisonHow to avoid an incomplete total
Platform and hostingThe qualifying plan, hosting and domain renewalRecord what the plan includes before adding another hosting charge
PaymentsPercentage fee, fixed fee and any platform transaction feeApply each fee to its stated payment methods and charge base
Applications or extensionsRequired licences, usage tiers and annual renewalsUse the tier needed for the catalogue and order volume
ConnectionsConnector subscription, setup and failed-sync recoveryPrice the actual records and direction of each transfer
MaintenanceUpdates, backups, monitoring and restore workName the supplier or employee responsible
Setup and exitData cleaning, migration, training and exportShow one-off cash costs separately from recurring work

For a percentage-plus-fixed payment tariff, calculate percentage times eligible payment value, then add the fixed fee times eligible transactions. Repeat for each payment method. Include any additional platform fee for an external processor only where the selected arrangement charges it.

Separate economic cost from cash timing. An annual licence paid upfront affects cash immediately, even if you divide it by twelve for comparison. Keep GST-inclusive cash payments and costs after recoverable tax in separate columns when your accounting treatment requires both.

Check sensitivity and omitted work

Change one assumption at a time to see which cost advantage survives. Order volume affects payment fees, while staffing and feature requirements can force a different plan or application tier.

Consider two entirely fictional proposals. These figures are assumptions, not Shopify or WooCommerce prices. All assumed supplier charges below exclude GST. Internal time uses a fully loaded cost of $50 an hour, without adding GST.

Fictional operating-cost comparison

Assumed costProposal AProposal B
Platform and hosting per month$150$100
Required applications and connections per month$100$70
Routine internal work per month4 hours, costing $2006 hours, costing $300
Monthly total before payment fees$450$470
One-off implementation$3,000$2,000
Three-year total before payment fees$19,200$18,920

Proposal B is $280 cheaper over three years under these assumptions. Its lower setup price outweighs its higher monthly operating cost. That result assumes the same payment cost and equivalent delivered functions.

If Proposal B needs two more hours of recovery work each month, it adds $100 monthly or $3,600 over three years. Its three-year total becomes $22,520. Proposal A then costs $3,320 less before payments.

Now double orders while keeping the average payment at $80. Eligible monthly payment volume rises from $80,000 to $160,000. A hypothetical 0.2 percentage point difference in processor rates then costs $320 a month, compared with $160 at the base volume. Fixed fees still depend on transaction count. More orders can also trigger an application’s next usage tier.

Change the staff requirement separately. An included account is an entitlement to use software. Configuring permissions, training staff and documenting refund approval are implementation tasks. Put those tasks in the proposal with an owner and an estimated time.

Assign ownership for each connection too. If an order export fails, someone must detect it, prevent duplicates and reconcile the recovered record. A connector licence does not establish who performs that work or whether recovery support is included.

Choose the complete operating fit

Choose the arrangement that meets every required workflow at an acceptable total cost under your likely workload. A hosted plan fits when its entitlements cover the store and its included infrastructure reduces work you would otherwise fund. A separately hosted arrangement fits when its control is useful and you have priced the people maintaining it.

Reject a cheaper proposal that omits required staff access or cannot preserve variant stock through the order workflow. Compare the remaining proposals under base volume, higher volume and a realistic recovery workload. Keep renewal prices and exit costs in the same comparison period.

Ask each shortlisted supplier to walk through one product update, one paid order and one refund using the proposed connections. Record the expected saved records and the person responsible for a failure. Select the proposal whose written scope and cost model both cover that complete flow.

Give your store its own shopping agent

Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.

See it in actionFree trial · Simple setup