Ecommerce merchandising that helps shoppers choose

Make your range easier to shop. Use category structure, product order and searchandising rules that balance relevance, availability and commercial goals.

Ecommerce merchandising organises and positions products so customers can find suitable options, compare them and decide what to buy. Start with one category objective, arrange the range around shopper needs and apply promotions only where they preserve relevance. Then test the route from discovery to purchase.

For a trading lead managing a large range, the starting point is one buying task customers struggle to complete. You’ll need access to category and search settings, current stock information and analytics that connect product exposure with purchases. Keep a copy of existing rules so you can reverse a change.

Set the merchandising objective

Choose a buying problem and a commercial outcome before changing product order. “Help customers choose a cabin bag that meets their airline’s size limit” gives you a clearer task than “get more clicks”.

For a hypothetical luggage category, your objective could be more purchases of suitable cabin bags from category visits. Record the constraints beside it. A promoted bag must meet the size requirement, have a purchasable variant and stay above your agreed margin floor after any discount.

A high-margin bag that exceeds the stated size limit fails the relevance condition. An eligible bag with little stock might suit a limited promotion, provided you remove it when the eligible variant sells out. Margin decides between suitable choices. It doesn’t make an unsuitable product relevant.

Write the intended outcome, eligible products and stopping conditions in a short rule record. Name the person responsible for reviewing it. Check the current category results before changing anything, so you have a baseline for the same shopper task.

Organise the catalogue for comparison

Build category paths and filters around the decisions customers make while choosing. In the luggage example, a customer might enter through cabin luggage, filter by external dimensions and price, then compare empty weight and capacity.

Separate the roles of each surface. Categories narrow the type of product. Filters apply requirements within that range. Product cards show enough detail to decide which items deserve a closer look. The product page supplies the measurements and explanations needed to make the final choice.

Shopify lets you change a collection’s product order, including a manual order, through its collection sorting settings. Its Search & Discovery filters refine products on collection pages and search results when the theme supports them. Choose a default order for the category’s task while keeping useful customer sorting options available.

A sensible layout still fails when its attributes are inconsistent. If one bag’s size excludes wheels while another includes them, customers can’t compare the measurements reliably. If compatible bags lack the size attribute used by a filter, the filter can remove suitable options.

Inspect the products that disappear after each filter selection. Agree on the meaning and units of comparison attributes before adding more filters. For the technical work of completing and standardising those records, use the product data enrichment guide.

Apply searchandising rules

Searchandising applies merchandising decisions to onsite search results. It changes which matching products receive attention when a customer enters a query. Keep the customer’s stated requirements ahead of a promotional preference.

Use this hypothetical luggage rule set as a starting point for testing:

Search situationMerchandising actionExpected result
Customer searches for cabin luggageBoost a new cabin bag that meets the category requirements and is availableThe relevant new bag gains exposure without replacing the range with promotions
A matching bag sells out completelyDemote it below available alternatives, keeping its availability visibleCustomers see purchasable choices before an unavailable product
Customer searches an exact bag modelExclude that query from the broad promotional ruleThe requested model stays easy to find, with its true stock status shown
Customer filters below a price limitKeep the limit as an eligibility conditionA commercial boost cannot insert a bag above the selected price

Shopify’s product boost documentation says boosts apply only to products available for sale. The app also lets you display, hide or place out-of-stock products last. These controls apply to Shopify’s native search. A third-party search app can behave differently, as its searchability guidance explains.

For an Algolia implementation, optional filters can move matching records up or down without removing them. The attributes must be declared for filtering, with the Filters ranking criterion enabled. A required filter removes ineligible records. Use that distinction when separating “prefer available stock” from “show only available stock”.

An exact-match exception is a merchandising requirement you configure and test, not a promise that every search engine automatically protects model queries. Algolia’s rule conditions can target the whole query or part of it and use a fixed validity period. Keep broad promotion triggers separate from model-specific searches.

Preview both the broad category query and an exact model query after changing a rule. If the requested model disappears, inspect matching conditions and filters before adding another boost. Each extra compensating rule adds another condition to diagnose.

Present complementary and promoted products

Choose product placements by the relationship they have to the item a customer is considering. A replacement bag and a luggage lock solve different needs, so give them different labels and positions.

PlacementWhat it helps the customer doLuggage example
Related itemsExplore other items with a relevant connectionOther bags in the same travel collection
SubstitutesChoose another product for the same jobA lighter cabin bag with the same dimensions
Complementary itemsAdd something that works with the chosen productA compatible luggage lock
BundleBuy a defined set togetherA cabin bag sold with packing cubes
Paid or commercial placementSee a product given extra exposure for a business reasonA supplier-funded featured bag, labelled as sponsored

State why an item is shown. Don’t present a paid placement as evidence that a product best meets the customer’s requirements. Check compatibility before recommending an accessory and show what a bundle contains. For component-based setup, follow the guide to Shopify bundles.

For a hypothetical summer travel campaign, promote selected lightweight cabin bags only within cabin-luggage categories and relevant broad searches. Require stock in the promoted variant and the agreed margin floor. Set a four-week expiry or stop at campaign end, whichever comes first. Stop earlier if eligibility fails.

Review the complementary products separately. Shopify’s recommendation requirements require complementary products to have inventory above zero. Continuing to sell out of stock doesn’t make them eligible for that recommendation type.

Check the buying experience

Walk through one complete buying task on mobile and desktop before exposing the change to customers. Use a specific brief, such as finding a cabin bag within a named airline’s published external dimensions and the customer’s budget.

  1. Start from navigation and enter the category. Confirm the category name matches the task and that the first products are plausible choices.
  2. Apply the relevant filters. Check that results respect every selection, including the size and availability of the selected variant.
  3. Repeat the task through search. Try a broad phrase and then an exact model name. Compare the results with the intended rules.
  4. Open two suitable product pages. Confirm that the same comparison attributes use the same units and that stock is clear before adding to the basket.
  5. Inspect the extra products and return to the results. Confirm that accessories are compatible and that the customer’s filter selections survive the return.

Record the point where a customer must guess. If “Does the height include the wheels?” remains unanswered, add the measurement explanation to product presentation. If the answer exists but search promotes an oversized bag, fix the rule.

Use category content to explain a decision at the point it arises. A short explanation of external dimensions can help customers use the filter correctly. Keep longer advice out of the way of the product list and make its product examples follow the same eligibility rules.

Measure and revise the rules

Compare discovery and product engagement with purchase outcomes under recorded test conditions. Click-through rate (CTR) shows whether exposed products earn clicks. It doesn’t show whether customers find a suitable item or complete a purchase.

For discovery, inspect searches with no results and repeated query changes. For product engagement, check whether product views lead to basket additions.

Define the denominator before comparing CTR. For a product placement, you could divide clicks by recorded impressions of that placement and multiply by 100. Keep that event definition unchanged between variants. A good click-through rate for a prominent category slot cannot establish a target for a different search placement.

Run a controlled comparison where traffic permits it. Keep the category, device mix and attribution window comparable, and record changes to stock, discounts or incoming traffic. If you compare consecutive periods instead, those differences can explain the result without the merchandising change causing it.

Use the following hypothetical result to avoid judging a rule on clicks alone. Each test variant records 10,000 placement impressions. The existing order produces 600 clicks and 30 attributed orders. The promoted order produces 800 clicks and 24 attributed orders.

CTR rises from 6% to 8%, but orders per impression fall from 0.3% to 0.24%. Inspect product-page exits and availability before expanding the rule. The extra clicks might come from a more attractive image while the promoted product fails the buying task.

Review margin after discounts alongside orders and inspect exact-model searches separately. A broad-query improvement can hide a worse result for customers who already know what they want. Keep a rule only when the evidence supports its objective and its guardrails hold. Otherwise remove it, restore the previous order and test the specific cause of the failed buying task.

Give your store its own shopping agent

Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.

See it in actionFree trial · Simple setup