Amazon vs Shopify for a retail seller

Choosing Amazon or Shopify changes who owns the storefront and customer relationship. Compare listings, orders, costs and the work of using both channels.

Choose Amazon when you want to sell within its marketplace and can meet its listing and service rules. Choose Shopify when you want your own storefront and direct customer relationship. Running both makes sense when your team can manage separate channel rules and keep shared stock accurate.

The Amazon vs Shopify decision also separates selling from fulfilment. Fulfilment by Amazon (FBA) handles stored stock and dispatch for a fee. A Shopify subscription gives you store software, while you arrange how orders reach customers.

Choose the channel responsibilities

Amazon supplies the marketplace and checkout, while Shopify supplies an online store you run under your brand. Neither removes your responsibility for accurate product information or enough stock to fulfil the orders you accept.

Match the channel to the customer

A seller with standard, clearly identified products can use Amazon to reach people shopping inside that marketplace. Your offer must satisfy Amazon’s category and listing requirements. Access to a marketplace doesn’t guarantee orders or profitable advertising.

Shopify suits a retailer that needs its own buying journey, merchandising and repeat-customer communication. You also need a way to attract shoppers. An existing customer list or store audience changes that workload, but doesn’t make acquisition free.

Use both when each channel has a purpose and the extra orders justify the administration. For example, Amazon can carry a selected range while Shopify carries the full catalogue. Each channel still needs correct prices and delivery promises.

Marketplace and store duties

ResponsibilityAmazonShopify
Storefront and checkoutAmazon controls the marketplace experienceRetailer configures its store within the selected plan
Product informationSeller supplies compliant listing dataRetailer supplies product pages and variants
DispatchSeller dispatches, or sends eligible stock to FBARetailer arranges warehouse, carrier or fulfilment provider
Customer contactAmazon’s communication rules applyRetailer manages customer profiles and marketing consent
Stock accuracySeller maintains available offer quantitiesRetailer maintains variant inventory and locations

With FBA, Amazon stores eligible inventory and handles picking, packing and shipping. It also handles customer service and returns for those orders. You still prepare inbound shipments, replenish stock and account for storage charges.

Self-fulfilment leaves packing and dispatch with your team. On Shopify, buying a label or installing an app doesn’t transfer responsibility for the parcel arriving as promised.

Compare the same listing and order

The same mug needs a separate sellable record and an accurate delivery promise on each channel. Consider a fictional retailer selling a blue ceramic mug in 350 ml and 500 ml sizes. The 500 ml version costs the customer $50 with delivery included.

Follow the 500 ml variant

On Amazon, match the exact product to an existing catalogue listing when one exists. Otherwise create its listing with the required identifiers and category attributes. Amazon’s new seller guide explains Global Trade Item Numbers (GTINs) and its own Amazon Standard Identification Numbers (ASINs). A valid exemption can replace the usual GTIN requirement.

Use the permitted variation relationship for the sizes. The seller’s stock keeping unit (SKU) identifies its offer for the 500 ml mug. A matching product name alone doesn’t prove two records represent the same variant.

In Shopify, create the mug and its size options. Variants let the retailer manage each combination and its inventory. Give the 500 ml mug a stable SKU and correct barcode, with its own price and available quantity.

For this example, both channels use the retailer’s warehouse. When a customer buys the 500 ml mug, the correct variant must be picked and its available quantity reduced. Amazon collects the marketplace payment. Shopify Payments processes the Shopify checkout payment. Each channel has its own order and settlement record.

If the mug arrives damaged, locate that channel’s order before starting the return. Amazon’s seller-fulfilled requirements govern the marketplace case. Shopify’s returns tools let staff create a return and issue a refund after handling the returned item. The retailer supplies its store policy and support process.

Keep customer permissions separate

Amazon’s seller code of conduct restricts customer information to permitted order handling and prohibits marketing communications. Importing an Amazon order into store software doesn’t grant permission to add that buyer to a marketing list.

Shopify creates customer profiles from interactions such as orders and account registration. Staff must record marketing consent separately. A customer record is not unrestricted permission to use or share personal information.

For both channels, keep the product’s dimensions and care instructions in the catalogue owner you nominate. Keep delivery and returns rules with their channel owner. A support answer needs the actual order’s channel, dispatch status and policy, even when both orders appear in one admin.

Compare fees and ongoing work

Compare costs using the same orders and fulfilment method before choosing a channel. This illustration assumes 100 one-mug orders per month at $50 each, all delivered from the retailer’s warehouse. Customers pay $5,000 in total, including any applicable product GST.

The Amazon setup uses Professional selling on Amazon Australia and the Home and Kitchen referral category. The Shopify setup uses Basic paid monthly and standard domestic cards through Shopify Payments. There are no paid apps in either standalone setup.

Illustrative monthly channel budget

CostAmazonShopify
Subscription$49.95 excluding GST$56 before applicable billing GST
Selling or payment charge13% referral fee: $650 excluding GST1.7% plus 30 cents per order: $115
Packing and outbound delivery allowance$800$800
Advertising allowance$200$200
Additional return handling allowance$40$40
Paid apps$0$0
Modelled subtotal$1,739.95$1,211

The subscription and selling rates come from Amazon’s fee schedule and Shopify’s Australian pricing. All other allowances are fictional planning inputs before GST. The subtotals exclude product cost, staff time and refunds, so they are not profit estimates. Any tax added to fees also sits outside these subtotals.

Shopify’s subscription is subject to its Australian billing GST rules. Eligible GST-registered businesses can add their ABN for the stated subscription exemption. Basic’s annual-billing equivalent is $42 per month, with the annual commitment separate from this monthly-payment example.

Amazon also has an Individual plan at $0.99 per item excluding GST, before referral and fulfilment charges. Shopify’s payment fee rules distinguish Shopify Payments from third-party payment providers. A different card type or provider changes the calculation.

Equal advertising allowances make the budget comparable, but don’t imply equal orders. If Shopify needs another $600 of advertising for those sales, its apparent fee saving disappears. If you switch Amazon orders to FBA, replace the warehouse allowance with applicable fulfilment and storage charges plus inbound preparation and freight.

Make one system responsible for shared stock

Shopify Marketplace Connect supports Amazon listings, inventory and order synchronisation. Its setup rules still require an approved marketplace seller account and marketplace shipping settings. Marketplace orders are paid by the marketplace.

In this example, nominate Shopify as the catalogue and warehouse-stock owner. Map each mug variant to its Amazon offer and assign one staff member to rejected listings or stock discrepancies. Keep FBA stock distinct from warehouse stock if you add it later.

Marketplace Connect includes the first 50 automatically synced marketplace orders per month. Further automatic order sync incurs a percentage charge with a monthly cap. Add that connector charge when budgeting for both channels.

A supported sync shares defined records. It doesn’t create a shared checkout or remove Amazon’s customer-data restrictions. Start with the channel whose customer relationship and fulfilment duties your team can support, then add the second when catalogue ownership and reconciliation are assigned.

Give your store its own shopping agent

Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.

See it in actionFree trial · Simple setup