BigCommerce vs Shopify for retailers in 2026
Your catalogue and checkout needs decide the platform. Compare Shopify and BigCommerce on SEO, integrations and total costs for your store’s next stage.
- Published
- Last updated
Choose Shopify over BigCommerce when your range fits its product model and you want its standard checkout with compatible apps. Choose BigCommerce when separate product modifiers, shared-catalogue storefronts or a custom checkout interface decide the project.
Neither choice removes integration work. The cost difference depends on the payment provider that processes your orders, the features your plan includes and who maintains your customisations.
The choice depends on your retail requirements
Shopify and BigCommerce both host your store, but their product models and checkout extension routes create different implementation costs. Compare a theme-based Shopify store with a theme-based BigCommerce store first. A separate, headless frontend adds development and hosting responsibilities to either option.
The following summary assumes one Australian online storefront and each platform’s native checkout. Higher plans and custom development enter the comparison only where a requirement needs them.
| Requirement | Shopify | BigCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Stocked product combinations | Up to 2,048 variants across three options per product | Up to 600 variants per product, with separate modifiers for customisation |
| Category organisation | Collections group products for browsing | Categories and subcategories form a hierarchy |
| Checkout interface changes | Information, shipping and payment UI extensions require Plus | Checkout SDK supports a custom interface built by developers |
| Several storefronts | Plus includes a main store and nine expansion stores for one brand, subject to contract terms | Multi-Storefront shares a catalogue and order administration across storefronts |
| Payment-related platform charges | Plan-specific third-party transaction fees | Open Payment Provider fees on applicable self-serve orders |
A higher variant count favours Shopify for some large product matrices. BigCommerce’s modifier model can be more useful when a customer enters engraving text or chooses gift wrapping without selecting another stocked item.
Handle the catalogue and its search visibility
The deciding catalogue question is whether a choice identifies stock or customises the item being bought. Shopify’s variant documentation lists three options and 2,048 variants per product. Extra options need an app or a different implementation, such as line-item properties.
BigCommerce’s variants and modifiers guide separates stocked combinations from customisation. Variants can carry their own stock keeping units (SKUs) and inventory. Modifiers cannot track separate inventory or have their own SKU.
For an illustrative personalised-jewellery range, metal and chain length can identify stocked variants, while an engraving field is a modifier. Treating every inscription as inventory creates the wrong product model. Conversely, a clothing range with 1,000 stocked combinations fits Shopify’s documented variant ceiling but exceeds BigCommerce’s 600-variant ceiling for one product.
Shopify uses collections for product groups. BigCommerce has nested categories, and products can belong to multiple categories. With BigCommerce Multi-Storefront, storefronts share a catalogue but can show different products and category structures. Orders retain storefront attribution in the shared orders area.
Shopify Plus expansion stores are separate stores. Its expansion-store guidance includes a main store and nine expansion stores under the Plus contract. Shared product and order operations across those stores need their own integration design. Multiple brands require separate Plus contracts under those terms.
Compare SEO controls with the rendered result
Both platforms let you edit product and category-equivalent search listings. Shopify’s collection settings include page titles, descriptions and URL handles, with an option to redirect the previous URL. Its hosted storefront uses the familiar /products/ and /collections/ routes. Editing a handle does not give you an arbitrary URL hierarchy.
BigCommerce’s SEO fields documentation describes configurable product and category URL formats, including custom formats. It also supports creating 301 redirects when changing those URLs. That control can reduce URL-mapping work when retaining an established category structure.
Faceted navigation needs separate attention because filters create additional URLs. Shopify’s Search & Discovery filters require a compatible theme. BigCommerce’s custom-field filters require Scale or higher. Its default robots.txt rules block crawling of filtered listing URLs.
A filter control does not create an optimised landing page by itself. Compare canonical tags and crawl rules on the chosen theme’s filtered pages. Structured data and visible content can change with the theme or an SEO app, even when the platform settings stay the same.
Shopify documents automatic canonical URLs in its SEO guidance. Preserve that behaviour when customising a theme. Neither a shorter URL nor a particular platform establishes a ranking or speed advantage on its own.
Compare checkout, payments and order support
Shopify keeps checkout changes within its extension system, while BigCommerce provides a route to building your own checkout interface. The difference becomes decisive when your buying process needs more than branding or a standard field setting.
Shopify allows basic checkout branding and some app extensions below Plus. Its checkout customisation rules reserve UI extensions on the information, shipping and payment pages for Plus. Public apps using Shopify Functions are available from Basic, while custom apps using Functions require Plus.
BigCommerce’s Checkout SDK exposes customer login and address operations, alongside configured shipping and payment methods. A developer can build a custom presentation around those operations. That freedom creates code your team or partner must maintain, including validation and payment-error handling.
Both platforms support payment-provider integrations. Provider availability and supported checkout methods determine whether your required payment flow works. Platform charges are separate from the processor’s card charges, so an existing gateway contract needs its own cost line.
Order support also depends on usable fulfilment data. Shopify’s order status page shows shipment updates once tracking details are added. Supported carriers provide richer tracking. Customer verification protects access to order information.
BigCommerce exposes order-status changes, order messages and refund events through its webhook events. A support integration can use those events with order details to show staff the current state. An order marked shipped still needs carrier tracking to answer where the parcel is.
Shopify integrations must also account for order access permissions. Standard order scopes cover the previous 60 days. Older-order access needs the additional scope and applicable approval. That distinction affects long warranty periods and support for older purchases.
Assess integrations and ongoing ownership
A marketplace app can remove custom development only when it supports the exact objects and direction your store needs. Both platforms have app marketplaces and application programming interfaces (APIs). A listing alone does not establish two-way synchronisation.
Consider a product update from your stock system. Shopify’s productSet guide uses the GraphQL Admin API’s productSet operation. BigCommerce’s catalogue API manages products and variants through its REST endpoints.
In either implementation, map the supplier’s identifier to the correct variant before updating price or availability. Decide which system owns each field. Otherwise, a later import can overwrite a manual correction in the store.
An order-status exchange runs in the other direction. Shopify publishes order and fulfilment webhook topics. BigCommerce publishes order-status events that include the order identifier and status change. Your connector then retrieves the details it needs and updates the destination system.
Those are separate workflows. A connector that imports products can still lack order updates, refund handling or shipment tracking. Its documentation must identify which objects it reads or writes and what triggers an update.
Assign operational ownership before signing. The app vendor maintains its connector, the platform maintains its APIs and your developer maintains custom mappings and checkout code. Your team needs someone responsible for failed updates, expired credentials and changes to API versions. Include a retry process that avoids creating duplicate orders.
Calculate a matched operating budget
Compare subscription, processing and platform fees separately, then add apps and development. Use the same order volume and payment mix for both platforms.
Shopify’s Australian pricing lists Basic at AUD $42, Grow at AUD $114 and Advanced at AUD $431 per month when billed yearly. Grow’s third-party transaction fee is 1%, compared with 2% on Basic and 0.6% on Advanced. These platform fees sit beside the external processor’s charges.
Shopify’s Australian billing guidance explains subscription Goods and Services Tax (GST) and the exemption for GST-registered businesses that supply their Australian Business Number. Apply the store’s actual tax status to the budget.
BigCommerce’s pricing page lists Core, Growth and Scale at USD $29, USD $79 and USD $299 per month respectively when billed annually. Those prices exclude tax. Performance has custom pricing starting at USD $1,499 per month with annual billing. Extra storefronts and required apps belong in the same budget.
BigCommerce’s plan and fee update applies Open Payment Provider fees of 2% on Core, 1% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale. Orders processed by Embedded Payment Providers avoid that fee. The fee calculation uses applicable Inclusive GMV, after its 10% reduction. Gross merchandise value (GMV) is the order-value measure used for these charges.
A worked payment-cost example
Assume 100 orders of AUD $100 each in a month. Both stores use an external processor quoting 1.8% plus AUD $0.30 per order. All BigCommerce orders use an Open Payment Provider. Assume the business qualifies for Growth and the fee base contains no adjustments beyond the published 10% reduction. Figures exclude tax.
| Monthly cost component | Shopify Grow | BigCommerce Growth |
|---|---|---|
| Subscription, paid annually | AUD $114 | USD $79, converted at the business’s billing exchange rate |
| Assumed external processing | AUD $210 | AUD $210 |
| Platform payment fee | AUD $100: 1% of AUD $10,000 | AUD $90: 1% of AUD $9,000 |
| Apps and maintenance | Add the actual app subscriptions and developer allowance | Add the actual app subscriptions and developer allowance |
The processing quote is illustrative, not a published rate from either platform. Combined processing and platform charges are AUD $310 for Shopify and AUD $300 for BigCommerce in this scenario. Neither subtotal includes the subscription or apps.
A provider change can alter that result. Shopify Payments changes Shopify’s processing and third-party fee treatment. An Embedded Payment Provider removes BigCommerce’s Open Payment Provider fee on the orders it processes.
BigCommerce also ties plan placement to sales. Core and Growth automatically upgrade at USD $30,000 and USD $100,000 of trailing-year Inclusive GMV respectively. Scale charges 0.9% above USD $33,333 of monthly Inclusive GMV and moves to Performance at USD $2 million trailing-year GMV. Model growth against those rules, not the old Standard, Plus and Pro thresholds.
For Shopify Plus vs BigCommerce Performance, compare written enterprise terms with the same storefront count and checkout scope. Shopify Plus pricing depends on contract terms and can include variable platform charges. A low entry subscription cannot offset a required enterprise checkout or substantial ongoing development.
Choose for the next stage of your store
Choose Shopify when your stocked variants fit its options model, your required apps support that model and its checkout extensions cover the buying journey. A range with hundreds of stock-tracked combinations per product can favour Shopify over BigCommerce’s lower per-product variant ceiling.
Choose BigCommerce when separate modifiers or a shared-catalogue Multi-Storefront operation remove recurring work for your team. Its custom checkout route can also justify the choice when a required interface exceeds Shopify’s lower-plan extension boundaries. Include the developers who maintain it in that decision.
Put the hardest product and the most demanding checkout requirement into the implementation scope before comparing quotes. Require each quote to name the supporting plan and the custom work. Select the platform that meets those requirements within the full operating budget.
Give your store its own shopping agent
Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.