Shopify vs Square for retail stores in 2026
Choose between Shopify and Square for online and counter sales. Compare shared stock, product discovery, checkout, returns and the complete running cost.
- Published
- Last updated
Choose Shopify when online product discovery and a custom storefront drive your retail plans. Choose Square when counter sales lead and you want to extend the same item library online with a lower entry cost.
The deciding detail is what happens after a sale. Shared stock helps only when online availability reflects the location holding the goods, and staff can find the original order when a customer returns it.
Choose by the channel that drives your store
Compare Shopify’s online store with Shopify point of sale (POS) against Square Online with Square for Retail. Both connect online and counter selling, but their paid upgrades solve different problems.
Shopify Basic includes an online store and casual POS selling. POS Pro adds retail features at each subscribed location. Square for Retail Free includes basic inventory and an online store. Retail Plus adds advanced stock tools and cross-location returns. Square Online Plus is a separate website upgrade, so the two Square plans named Plus aren’t interchangeable.
| Decision | Shopify | Square |
|---|---|---|
| Main reason to choose it | Build online merchandising around a configurable storefront | Extend counter selling through the same Square item library |
| Entry configuration | Basic online store with included POS features | Retail Free with Online Free |
| Store operations upgrade | POS Pro per location | Retail Plus per location |
| Website upgrade boundary | Theme compatibility and checkout plan restrictions | Online Plus for custom domain and expanded design controls |
A retailer selling a small range at the counter has different needs from one guiding customers through hundreds of similar products. Match the configuration to that work before comparing subscription totals.
One catalogue across online and counter sales
Keep Shopify’s product and location inventory as the stock record for a Shopify setup. In a Square setup, use Square’s item library and location counts. A separate spreadsheet needs reconciliation whenever it disagrees with that record.
Both systems handle size and colour variations. Stock must belong to the actual variation: a navy medium shirt can sell out while a navy large remains available. Location settings then determine which stock can fulfil an online order.
Consider an illustrative shop with one navy medium shirt left, on its counter shelf. That shop also fulfils online orders from the same location.
- In Shopify, the counter sale reduces that location’s stock. With tracking enabled and online overselling disabled, zero available stock prevents another online purchase. Stock at a location that doesn’t fulfil online orders won’t make the item available online. Shopify POS can still sell below zero after warning staff.
- In Square, the sale updates the shared inventory. Tracked variations can become sold out automatically at zero. The website item must also have the right channel assignment and fulfilment settings. Square’s item setup guidance explains those website controls.
The customer consequence is the same: staff must answer from the remaining variation stock, not yesterday’s product description. If the last unit has already been promised twice, someone must resolve fulfilment or arrange a refund. Neither shared inventory nor a stock badge removes the need to record sales promptly.
Online discovery and checkout controls
Shopify is the stronger choice when you need to shape how customers narrow a large range. Square fits a store that can sell through categories and item pages without extensive storefront work.
Use the same illustrative request for both: a navy cotton shirt in medium, available for collection. The customer needs to find shirts, inspect the material, select medium and see the collection option before paying.
With Shopify, collections and Search & Discovery filters can support that journey. Storefront filters require a compatible theme. Creating a colour filter alone doesn’t make it appear on the page. Material data and variant images still need to be supplied and maintained by the retailer.
Square’s item categories and variations support a simpler path into the same purchase. Its item library controls website visibility and online sale prices. Square Online Plus adds website themes and expanded design controls. Paying for Retail Plus alone doesn’t establish that those website features are included.
Carry the selected size into the basket and show the collection location at checkout in either setup. A missing material description is a content problem. A hidden filter can be a theme setting. An app requirement adds its own recurring cost.
Shopify also has a platform boundary: apps that change the checkout’s information, shipping and payment pages require Shopify Plus. Basic doesn’t provide unrestricted checkout editing. For the steps that affect purchase completion after you choose the platform, use the checkout optimisation guide.
Payment, POS and subscription costs
Square has the lower subscription entry point, while Shopify’s running cost depends on its store plan and each POS Pro location. Compare ordinary card payments separately from subscriptions and equipment.
The following example assumes a new Square account and Shopify Basic using Shopify Payments. It uses published starting card rates, ordinary card payments and one shop. Shopify subscription figures exclude goods and services tax (GST). An account with qualifying GST registration and an Australian Business Number is exempt from the additional 10%. Processing fees from Shopify Payments include GST.
| Cost item | Shopify | Square |
|---|---|---|
| Entry website and POS subscription | Basic: $56 per month, or $42 per month billed yearly, before applicable GST | Retail Free and Online Free: $0 per month plus processing |
| Paid counter operations | POS Pro: add $129 per month per location to the store plan | Retail Plus: listed at $109 per month per location, plus processing |
| Paid website options | Paid themes and apps depend on the chosen setup | Online Plus: listed at $36 per month billed annually; Premium: $99 per month billed annually |
| Standard online card rate | From 1.7% + $0.30 per transaction on Basic | 2.2% on Online Free and Plus; 1.9% on Premium |
| Standard in-person card rate | From 1.85% on Basic | 1.6% for a new account |
| Incremental hardware for compatible-phone Tap to Pay | $0 when using an existing supported phone | $0 when using an existing supported phone |
Square’s subscription total depends on the retail and website upgrades you buy. Its quoted card-processing percentages include GST. Older Square accounts can have different in-person rates under its fee schedule.
Consider an illustrative month with $10,000 online sales across 100 payments and $10,000 in counter sales. The starting rates produce these processing costs:
- Shopify Basic: $200 online and $185 in person, totalling $385 including GST on processing fees.
- Square Online Free with Retail Free: $220 online and $160 in person, totalling $380 including GST on processing fees.
The $5 processing difference in that example is much smaller than a paid subscription. Add the plan charges separately. Shopify Basic’s 2% third-party-provider fee also matters if you use another online payment provider. Higher Shopify plans change rates and subscription costs together.
Tap to Pay is a narrow equipment assumption. A permanent counter can also need a tablet, printer or barcode scanner. Budget for the same equipment on both sides, plus any paid theme, domain renewal and required apps. Square Online Premium’s lower online rate saves 0.3 percentage points against Plus. Its higher annual-billing subscription needs enough online volume to justify that saving.
Returns and orders across channels
Staff need the original transaction, the refund action and the correct restock location for a cross-channel return. A customer profile alone doesn’t establish that the goods have come back or that an order has been fulfilled.
In Shopify POS, staff open the order, select Return or exchange and choose whether to restock at their assigned location. They then select the refund method. POS Pro adds exchanges and cross-location retail features. Shopify’s refund instructions also identify an operational limit: an admin return already in progress must be closed before POS can refund it. Some third-party-channel refunds need the admin instead.
In Square Retail, staff can locate a transaction by receipt number or through the customer’s transaction history. They select items to restock and process the refund or exchange. Cross-location returns require Retail Plus or Premium. The Square returns procedure distinguishes returning stock from issuing money back.
For an online order, staff must also inspect its fulfilment record. Square’s documented cross-location order flow routes fulfilment to one selected location. It doesn’t split a single order across locations or fulfilment types. A returned item therefore needs to land in the stock count of the shop that physically receives it.
Customer history helps staff recognise a purchase when the sale is attached to the right profile. Record the order number and the outcome of the return so a second staff member can continue. The ecommerce customer service guide covers the support process around those records.
Select the setup that fits daily work
Choose Shopify if online merchandising needs justify ongoing storefront configuration and a paid platform subscription. Include POS Pro where your stores need its exchange and staff controls. The compromise is a larger fixed bill and responsibility for the theme and apps you choose.
Square fits a counter-led shop adding straightforward online ordering from its existing item library. Start with Free only when its actual website and return workflow meet your needs. The compromise is paying for separate retail and website upgrades as those requirements grow.
Before committing to either setup, run one realistic store rehearsal:
- Sell the last medium shirt at the counter. Confirm its online availability changes while the large remains available.
- Place an online order for the large with collection at the intended shop. Find that order on the staff device and confirm the fulfilment status.
- Return the collected shirt through the staff workflow. Confirm the refund attaches to the original payment and the correct shop receives the stock.
Price the configuration that completes those actions with your actual staff permissions. That configuration is the useful comparison for your store.
Give your store its own shopping agent
Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.