Etsy vs Shopify: choose the selling responsibilities

Compare Etsy and Shopify by eligibility, fees, discovery and control. Check who owns the catalogue, customer journey and support before choosing a channel.

Etsy vs Shopify comes down to where you want to sell and which responsibilities you can take on. Choose Etsy for eligible creative goods when you want a shop inside a marketplace. Choose Shopify when you want your own storefront and can bring customers to it. Use both only when you can keep stock and customer support consistent across two channels.

Choose Etsy, Shopify or both

Etsy is a marketplace shop. Shopify is the platform for a store you operate. An existing audience makes the Shopify option more practical because you already have people to send to your site. Etsy gives eligible products another discovery route, but a listing does not guarantee visits or sales.

Eligibility comes first. Etsy’s Creativity Standards cover goods made, designed, handpicked or sourced by sellers under specific rules. A retailer selling ordinary mass-produced stock cannot assume that the whole catalogue qualifies. Original designs made by a production partner and eligible craft supplies have different requirements.

Selling responsibilities at a glance

DecisionEtsyShopify
Where customers shopYour shop within Etsy’s marketplaceYour own storefront
Product eligibilityEtsy’s creative categories and seller rulesYour products must meet applicable platform, payment and legal requirements
Discovery workMake listings useful for marketplace searchesBring customers through your own marketing and available sales channels
PresentationWork within Etsy’s listing and shop structureChoose a theme and configure the store
Operating commitmentMaintain listings and fulfil marketplace ordersMaintain the site alongside products, fulfilment and marketing
Second-channel workReconcile Etsy sales with stock elsewhereReconcile store sales with stock elsewhere

A ceramicist with a small eligible range can begin with Etsy while learning which products sell. A retailer with repeat customers and a broader catalogue has a stronger reason to operate a Shopify store. Both examples describe fit, not expected sales.

Two channels mean two places where a product can sell before the other channel knows stock has changed. They also mean separate order references and customer conversations. Keep one channel until your team has a reliable way to reconcile those differences.

Compare costs on the same order assumptions

Etsy charges per listing and sale, while Shopify adds a recurring store subscription. Compare their charges against the same sales volume before choosing on price.

Etsy’s fee policy lists USD $0.20 for a new or renewed listing and a 6.5% transaction fee. Listings expire after four months. A setup charge can apply. Etsy Plus is optional, not a requirement for a standard marketplace shop.

For Australian bank accounts, Etsy Payments processing costs 3% plus AUD $0.25 for domestic orders. International orders cost 4% plus AUD $0.25. Processing applies to the total payment, including postage and applicable sales tax.

Shopify’s Australian pricing lists Basic at AUD $56 per month on monthly billing. Annual billing is AUD $42 per month equivalent. Basic lists domestic online standard card processing at 1.7% plus AUD $0.30. Other cards and international payments have different rates. Basic also lists a 2% third-party transaction fee when applicable, separate from the payment provider’s own charges.

Fictional domestic-order cost comparison

Assume 100 orders in one month at AUD $100 each, with one item per order and no separately charged postage. Use Basic on monthly billing with Shopify Payments. The figures exclude tax on platform fees and show listed charges before any tax credits.

ChargeEtsyShopify Basic
Sales used for comparisonAUD $10,000AUD $10,000
Store subscriptionStandard shop, no required monthly subscriptionAUD $56
Transaction chargeAUD $650No third-party transaction fee in this Shopify Payments example
Domestic payment processingAUD $325AUD $200
Listing charges assumed100 chargeable listing events: USD $20No per-product listing charge in the plan
Subtotal before exclusionsAUD $975 plus USD $20 converted by EtsyAUD $256

The Shopify subtotal is lower in this example. It does not price the work of acquiring those 100 customers. Etsy’s marketplace discovery and a retailer’s own marketing are different routes to an order.

The model excludes unsold listings, additional renewals, setup charges and optional subscriptions. It also excludes advertising, domains, themes, apps, delivery costs and staff time. Refunds and disputes can change the result. Goods and services tax (GST) on service charges belongs in your actual cash budget according to your billing status.

Etsy Ads uses a daily advertising budget. Offsite Ads adds 15% or 12% on attributed orders, subject to Etsy’s sales threshold and participation rules. Participation becomes mandatory after the qualifying threshold. These are separate costs from payment processing.

Etsy adds 2.5% conversion when listing and payment-account currencies differ. Shopify’s international selling arrangements can also introduce conversion charges. Keeping the example domestic avoids treating currency conversion as free or assuming the same fee on both platforms.

Compare the customer’s product and support journey

On Etsy, customers find a listing within the marketplace, select the available options and complete checkout through Etsy. The seller supplies product information and shop policies within that structure. Etsy’s seller policy makes the seller responsible for accurate listings, dispatch commitments and timely replies.

For a made-to-order item, the listing must explain the selected size or finish and any personalisation. A customer asking about delivery needs the seller’s processing time as well as the carrier’s transit time. A marketplace interface does not remove the seller’s responsibility to give accurate answers.

On Shopify, the retailer configures the product page and navigation. Shopify product variants represent combinations such as size and colour, with inventory managed per variant. Your team decides which product facts and policy links customers see before checkout.

After purchase, Etsy customers contact the seller through the marketplace’s messaging and help processes. The seller handles the request under shop policies and Etsy’s rules. Do not move an Etsy-initiated transaction elsewhere to avoid fees: Etsy prohibits off-platform transactions.

Shopify retailers manage orders in their admin. Shopify’s returns documentation describes returns, shipping instructions and refunds. Optional self-serve returns let customers request a return from their order status page. Your team still decides the permitted return and carries it out.

Shopify’s app and theme system gives you a way to add storefront assistance. An app must support the specific job you need, including access controls for order information. An Etsy marketplace shop is a different installation surface. A website embed or Shopify app does not establish permission or compatibility for an Etsy listing.

Operate the chosen channel reliably

Shopify’s Marketplace Connect setup guide says new Etsy connections cannot be made through that app. Existing Etsy connections can continue. Do not plan a new two-channel operation around an unavailable connection.

A manually maintained Etsy shop alongside Shopify remains a manual process. Before using another connector, establish its supported objects and sync direction. A product export alone does not prove that stock, cancellations or refunds synchronise.

Before opening the second channel, complete these checks:

  1. Identify the eligible Etsy products and keep evidence for their listing category and any production partner.
  2. Choose one stock authority. Map each sellable variant to both channel records, then assign someone to resolve mismatches.
  3. Record both order references when an order moves between systems. Keep the original channel visible to fulfilment and support staff.
  4. Assign an inbox owner for each channel. Keep delivery promises and return instructions consistent with the actual order and applicable platform rules.
  5. Reconcile a sale, cancellation and return before expanding the shared range. Confirm that available stock and the refund record match the action taken.

For a one-off item, reserve stock on the other channel as soon as it sells. If you cannot do that reliably, offer the item on one channel. Add the second channel when your operating process can protect the promise you make to each customer.

Give your store its own shopping agent

Customers ask in their own words. Your agent finds, compares and checks out from your catalogue, right on your site.

See it in actionFree trial · Simple setup